Stuff & Nonsense Home

Where you’ll find designer, author and speaker Andy Clarke. The bastard.

Blogging And All That Malarkey

Do UK government web sites need to look exactly the same in every browser?

No, they don’t. As Jeremy Keith so kindly pointed out, it’s a subject that I have been banging on about for quite a while now.

I know it's the right approach, you know it's the right approach. One of the problem's has been that people who are less enlightened are usually the same people who commission our work and pay to keep our children eating something other than coal.

Sure, there have been big players in the internet industry, big players like Yahoo!, who have championed progressive enhancement, progressive enrichment or transcendent css, but somehow their lead often fails to convince clients who can see little in common between a Silicon Valley giant and their own business.

Now, if you work in the UK at least, and you believe that web sites don't need to look exactly the same in every browser, the UK government's own browser testing guidelines support you. (Hat tip to Bruce Lawson)

Section 39 lays it out for you:

You should check that the content, functionality and display all work as intended. However, there may be minor differences in the way that the website is displayed. The intent is not that it should be pixel perfect across browsers, but that a user of a particular browser does not notice anything appears wrong.

I think my heart just skipped a beat.

From today I am quoting that paragraph in the standard, killer contract that I send out with every project. Maybe you will be doing the same?

Leave your comment

Cole Henley

January 20 2009 @ 09:32pm #

As, until recently, a government employee I was constantly harping on to my employers that as long as the core functionality is always there you can accept the fact that users are likely to have difference visual experiences across different browsers. When you go on to explain the likely cost of achieving pixel perfection across different user agents that can ‘lubricate’ your argument somewhat.

The main obstacle, however, is the pace with which public bodies themselves role out and upgrade their browsers. I can imagine most public sector bodies are locked down to the Windows environment, and a large proportion of those will still be running IE6 on most of their machines. When the decision makers are running relic software it does hamper your efforts to champion progressive enhancement in the visual design and delivery of public sector websites.

scrumpyjack

January 20 2009 @ 10:21pm #

hell yes I will!!!!

Rob Mason

January 20 2009 @ 10:45pm #

Christ! That’s what a real organisation should do, not what we’ve come to expect form the government. I need a lie down.

Matt Robin

January 20 2009 @ 11:09pm #

I previously commented over at WaSP, and yes - this is startling stuff indeed. The former approach (by the Government) of trying to get everything right for every browser - or fail - was definitely not working…pixel-perfection is a myth!  What I like is that the updated document accounts for working with standards-compliant browsers in particular (another step in the right direction eh?!)

Fed here from ‘Stuff and Nonsense’, I don’t have a feed for this site though - is this the one you’re blogging at from now on?

bruce

January 20 2009 @ 11:54pm #

I know people have been pretty down on the web standards project since the debacle with the microsoft metatag, but this was a big win for the community, by the community. 400 people writing to the government with considered, reasoned objections led to something pretty damn decent.

I’m proud to have played a part in it.

If only the guidelines were mandatory!

Amanda

January 24 2009 @ 06:09am #

That is a definite quote-worthy line from the government. It’s not often you see that kind of cooperation and helpfulness from the dept upstairs, whether it be governmental or corporate. Great find!

On another note, I thought you’d like to know that the web standards project is still inspiring artistic hearts; I’ve just started a blog on web standards and conventions, and thought you might like to have a look:

http://atdesign-breakingtheice.blogspot.com/

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Hardboiled Web Design

Hardboiled Web Design by Andy Clarke

How the latest technologies and techniques will make your websites more creative, flexible and adaptable. Get hardboiled in all formats from Five Simple Steps. Digital formats also available at Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk and the iBooks store.

We’ve deconstructed this site to focus on content while we restyle. Expect wonkiness during the transition.